Anatomy of a Murder
Film Analysis: Anatomy of a Murder
The Anatomy of Murder (1958) is a novel that had been written by the Supreme Court Justice of Michigan John D Voelker. The story had been based on a 1952 case of murder in which Voeckler was the defense attorney. The novel was then adapted into a movie by the screenwriter Wendell Mayes.
Two humble ex-district attorneys of the Michigan Paul Biegler and Parnell McCarthy took to the United States Army Lieutenant Manion (Ben Gazzara). Manion has been accused of shooting and killing the Thunder Bay Inn Owner, Barney Quill. It is alleged that Quill beat and raped the wife Laura who is known to be at the bar as the seductive and good time lady.
With only a little memory of the real murder, the only defense for Paul is “irresistible impulse.” This is a version of a temporary insanity even though his defense is weak. To add on, the prosecuting attorney Brooks West has called in a very prominent state assistant attorney general George Scott to assist in the prosecution (Bosley, 1959)
In term of the story line, Anatomy of Murder, Ben Gazzara (Fredrick Manion) is a lieutenant in the army and has been arrested for the murder of the bartender Barney Quill. Ben in his defense claims that the victim had raped and had beaten up his wife, Laura (Lee Remick). Even though Laura supports the story of her husband, there is no evidence to be found by the police surgeon that the victim had indeed been raped.
Social psychology comes in the court room during the cross examination of Manion by Paul Biegler, his defense lawyer. He is a lawyer is a humble small town. In the interviewing process, Biegler notices that Manion is very violent, possessive and jealous and that the wife had the reputation of granting her favors to the other men. Such discovery makes Biegler forecast that the prosecution might try to make the court believe that indeed Laura was the bartender’s lover.
Manion had killed him and beaten her up in the mere discovery that they were together. Manion further pleads not to be guilty and Biegler, knowing his case is weak chooses to set out his assistants to investigate the witness that will save Manion. Manion does not deny the murder but affirms that Quill raped his wife. Even with the experienced motivation, it would be tough to get Manion being cleared out of murder. Manion clarifies that he had no memory of the event, and this leads to the suggestion that he could be eligible for the defense against irresistible impulse that is a version of a temporary insanity defense.
The folksy speech of Biegler and his laid-back demeanor tend to hide a sharp legal mind and the propensity for the courtroom theatrics that makes the judge busy with maintenance of things in control. However, the defense case does not sink well primarily because the local district attorney Brooks West is being assisted by the highly-powered prosecutor George Scott, who is from the general office of the attorney.
Moreover, the prosecution at every circumstance tries to block any mention of the motive of Manion to kill Quill. Biegler, therefore, manages to get the rape case of Laura Manion into the record. The tactic used by Biegler and Manion during this moment prompts Judge Weaver to agree to allow such a matter to be a component of the deliberations.
Later on, the psychiatrists also give in some conflicting testimonies to the state of mind of Manion at the moment when he murdered Quill. The dancers, however, affirm that Manion could have suspected his wife Laura of cheating since he had asked the wife to swear on the rosary that Quill had raped him. More doubts are raised as to whether the act by Manion was non-consensual.
During the trial, Laura reveals that Quill tore off the pants while raping her. On the contrary, there was no evidence of the panties being found at the scene of the crime where she alleges that the abuse had taken place. Biegler in his defense suggests that Quill could have dropped the panties in the laundry room’s inn so that he could avoid any suspicion.
The central conflict and the most dramatic fascination from this section of the movie reveal the battle of the legal wits and the personalities that are waged between the defense attorney and those of the prosecution. Upon the watchful eye of the shrewd, the sardonic old judge. The battle is beautifully drawn and maneuvered. It is full of neat little triumphs from both sides thus; the result is an exciting climax and a clear revelation of the principal characters (Asimow, 1998).
The most intensely revealed are the character of the defense lawyer. This part played by James Stewart in his finest performances. He slowly and subtly represents a warm, knowledgeable, competent and a complex personality. Most importantly, the portrait of a trial lawyer in an action upon which can be difficult for any person to surpass. A good lawyer like Biegler would use social psychology in collaboration with the accused to turn the case around and obtain a favorable verdict. Manion and Biegler were the masters of the art as signified by the final outcome of the case. The five minutes section could have been the point that delivered the victory.
Bosley, C. (1959) Anatomy of a Murder Screen: A Court Classic
Asimow, M. (1998). “Picturing Justice Film review from a legal perspective”
At 111papers.com, we value all our customers, and for that, always strive to ensure that we deliver the best top-quality content that we can. All the processes, from writing, formatting, editing, and submission is 100% original and detail-oriented. With us, you are, therefore, always guaranteed quality work by certified and experienced writing professionals. We take pride in the university homework help services that we provide our customers.
As the best homework help service in the world, 111 Papers ensures that all customers are completely satisfied with the finished product before disbursing payment. You are not obligated to pay for the final product if you aren’t 100% satisfied with the paper. We also provide a money-back guarantee if you don’t feel that your paper was written to your satisfaction. This guarantee is totally transparent and follows all the terms and conditions set by the company.Read more
All products that we deliver are guaranteed to be 100% original. We check for unoriginality on all orders delivered by our writers using the most advanced anti-plagiarism programs in the market. We, therefore, guarantee that all products that we submit to you are 100% original. We have a zero-tolerance policy for copied content. Thanks to our strict no plagiarized work rule, you can submit your homework to your professor without worrying.Read more
TThis is one of the most cherished courtesy services that we provide to help ensure that our customers are completely satisfied with our finished products. Delivering the best final product to our customers takes multiple inputs. 111papers.com prides itself on delivering the best university homework help services in the writing industry. And, in part, our free revision policy is how we do it. What’s more, all our revisions are 100% free without any strings attached.Read more
Client privacy is important to use. We know and understand just how important customers value their privacy and always want to safeguard their personal information. Thus, all the information that you share with us will always remain in safe custody. We will never disclose your personal information to any third party or sell your details to anyone. 111 Papers uses the most sophisticated, top-of-the-line security programs to ensure that our customers’ information is safe and secured.Read more
Placing your order with us means that you agree with the homework help service we provide. We, in turn, will endear to ensure that we do everything we can to deliver the most comprehensive finished product as per your requirements. We will also count on your cooperation to help us deliver on this mandate. Yes, we also need you to ensure that you have the highest-quality paper.Read more